Second Circuit revives Fourth Amendment claim against public-hospital psychiatrist over a ten-minute commitment evaluation

· 6 min read · By Brandon J. Grable

Case: Rene v. Mustafa, No. 24-936, 2026 U.S. App. LEXIS 35166 (2d Cir. Nov. 18, 2026) (published; opinion by Judge Kovner, a district judge sitting by designation, joined by Judge Merriam; Judge Kahn concurring in part). Read the opinion

The short version

In July 2015, Diana Rene went to the emergency room at Stony Brook University Hospital, a state-run hospital in New York, with chest pain, weakness, nausea, headaches, and jaw pain. A psychiatrist there, Dr. Tanzia Mustafa, decided Rene was a substantial suicide risk and arranged for her to be transported to a private psychiatric hospital for involuntary commitment, where two staff psychiatrists ordered her committed.

Rene sued under 42 U.S.C. § 1983, claiming the commitment was an unreasonable seizure under the Fourth Amendment. She said Dr. Mustafa met with her only once, for "less than ten minutes." A psychiatrist who reviewed the record, Dr. Stastny, said an evaluation that short falls well below professional standards. The trial court threw out her sworn account as a "sham affidavit," granted summary judgment, and held that Dr. Mustafa had qualified immunity.

On Nov. 18, 2026, the Second Circuit reversed as to Dr. Mustafa. It held that the trial court should not have disregarded Rene's affidavit or Dr. Stastny's report, and that, taking her evidence as true, a jury could find Dr. Mustafa "could not have made an objectively reasonable determination of probable cause, precluding her qualified immunity defense."

What the court decided

An involuntary commitment is a seizure. The court explained that the Second Circuit recognizes a Fourth Amendment right against involuntary hospitalization, which it has described as "tantamount to the infringement of being arrested." Because Rene was hospitalized without a warrant, the seizure required probable cause, meaning "reasonable grounds for believing that the person seized is dangerous to herself or to others."

A plaintiff can explain her own testimony. The trial court excluded Rene's affidavit because it went further than what she said at her deposition. The appeals court said that was error. The "sham affidavit" rule is narrow: it applies only to contradictions that are "real, unequivocal, and inescapable." As the court put it, "A witness does not unequivocally contradict her prior testimony by providing context or explanations, even if a jury would be free not to credit them." Rene's affidavit added context, such as explaining that a remark about her facial pain was frustration, not a suicidal thought. That was for a jury to weigh. And because the affidavit came back in, so did Dr. Stastny's report that relied on it.

A jury question on qualified immunity. Taking Rene's evidence as true, a jury could find that Dr. Mustafa saw her once for less than ten minutes, that Rene never expressed suicidal thoughts to her, and that professional norms required a psychiatrist to check key chart entries by interviewing the patient before committing her. On that record, the court held, a jury could conclude that Dr. Mustafa "could not have made an objectively reasonable determination of probable cause, precluding her qualified immunity defense," so summary judgment for her was reversed. Even if a jury credited only Rene's deposition estimate of "probably 12 to 15 minutes," the court said a jury could reach the same conclusion.

The private-hospital doctors. The court affirmed summary judgment for the two psychiatrists at the private hospital. They were not state actors, so § 1983 did not reach them. The court acknowledged that a jury crediting Rene could find their evaluations "hasty or substandard," but held that relying too heavily on a state doctor's work does not turn a private doctor into a state actor.

Other rulings. The court affirmed dismissal of a separate § 1983 count that rested on a New York Mental Hygiene Law violation, because § 1983 requires a violation of federal law. It reinstated Rene's state-law claims and sent the case back to the trial court.

The concurrence. Judge Kahn agreed to reverse as to Dr. Mustafa but wrote that, on the current record, it was not clear to her that Rene's affidavit and Dr. Stastny's supplemental report create a material dispute that defeats qualified immunity. She would allow limited discovery on whether a minimum length of face-to-face examination, by itself, is material to the standard of care.

Why this matters

For more, see our pages on false arrest and unlawful seizure and qualified immunity.

This post is for general information only. It is not legal advice and does not create an attorney-client relationship. Every case depends on its own facts, and past results do not guarantee future outcomes.

Attorney responsible for content: Brandon J. Grable, Grable PLLC, 12451 Starcrest Dr, Suite 206, San Antonio, TX 78216, (210) 963-5297, intake@grable.law. Office visits are by appointment only; calls and emails are accepted 24/7.

Topics: Fourth Amendment · Qualified Immunity

How Grable PLLC Can Help

Section 1983 & Police Misconduct

Unlawful arrests, excessive force, retaliation, and other constitutional violations by police and government officials.

Police Excessive Force

Claims under the Fourth Amendment and Section 1983 when police use more force than the situation called for.

See also: case results and case updates.

Talk with Grable PLLC. Call 210-963-5297 or email intake@grable.law.

Request a Consultation