Divided Fifth Circuit says a Texas coach who refused board members' handshakes did not plausibly allege he spoke as a private citizen

· 7 min read · By Brandon J. Grable

Case: Lucio v. Brownsville Indep. Sch. Dist., No. 25-40746, ___ F.4th ___, 2026 U.S. App. LEXIS 32473 (5th Cir. Oct. 23, 2026) (published; opinion by Judge Higginson, joined by Judge Stewart; Judge Ho dissenting in part). Read the opinion

The short version

A Brownsville ISD teacher and coach brought his students to a school board meeting where the board honored their success at a statewide competition. Walking down the receiving line, he declined to shake hands with several board members and district officials. He said "Thank you. God bless you" instead. He later received a written warning and, he alleges, was transferred to another school. He sued under 42 U.S.C. § 1983, claiming First Amendment retaliation.

On Oct. 23, 2026, the Fifth Circuit affirmed the dismissal of his case. The majority held that his complaint did not plausibly show he acted as a private citizen. He was at the meeting because he was the coach. Judge Ho dissented on that point. In his view, whether the coach was doing his job or speaking for himself was a fact question that should not have been decided on the pleadings.

What happened

The court took the facts from the complaint, as it must at this stage. The coach founded the school's Texas Public Safety Association club and personally coached one of its teams. After the students placed in several events at a state competition, the district invited the students and "several sponsors, including Lucio," to a "regularly scheduled" board meeting to congratulate them. The complaint called the meeting a "purely political event."

As the line moved, the coach declined to shake hands with a lawyer for the school district, three board members, the board president, and a former superintendent. He shook hands with three other board members and the other employees in the line. The complaint gave two kinds of reasons. Some were personal: he believed some officials had treated him and his son unfairly in an earlier school dispute. Others were political: he believed the officials were "not fit for [their] job[s]," he intended to vote against them, and he did not want "a false image of an endorsement."

The district issued a "Notice of Warning." It cited a policy requiring employees to relate "to colleagues and supervisors with respect, courtesy, and in a professional manner."

What the court decided

The legal test. When a public employee claims retaliation for speech, the Fifth Circuit applies a two-step test drawn from Pickering v. Board of Education and Garcetti v. Ceballos. First, the employee must have spoken as a citizen on a matter of public concern. If not, the claim ends there. If so, the court balances the employee's interest in speaking against the employer's interest in running its operations. As the Supreme Court put it in Garcetti, "when public employees make statements pursuant to their official duties, the employees are not speaking as citizens for First Amendment purposes, and the Constitution does not insulate their communications from employer discipline."

Employee, not citizen. The majority assumed, without deciding, that the coach's refusal to shake hands qualified as protected speech. It then held that the complaint did not plausibly allege the coach acted as a private citizen. He attended the meeting "in his capacity as a coach," at the board's invitation, while his team was being honored. The court called his allegations that he spoke "as a citizen" and that the meeting was a "political event" "conclusory." It also said his conduct was directed internally and "up the chain of command" at district officials, not outward to the public.

Why Kennedy did not help him. The coach compared his case to Kennedy v. Bremerton School District, where the Supreme Court held that a football coach's brief post-game prayer was private speech. The Fifth Circuit distinguished it. In Kennedy, the Fifth Circuit noted, the coach did not speak pursuant to school policy, was not actively coaching or interacting with players when he prayed, and prayed after the game, when coaches were free to attend to personal matters. Here, the majority said, the coach's actions "ow[ed their] existence" to his role, "accepting congratulations on behalf of his team." The court added that the district's courtesy policy directly governed his conduct.

Because the coach did not plausibly allege he spoke as a citizen, the court did not decide whether his speech touched a matter of public concern.

The other claims. The court also affirmed dismissal of a Fifth Amendment claim based on the school's questioning of his son. Under Chavez v. Martinez, the court explained, that claim requires a compelled statement used in a criminal case, and the complaint did not allege one. A free-speech claim under Article I, § 8 of the Texas Constitution failed for the same reasons as the federal claim. The plaintiffs did not show that the Texas provision gives broader protection here.

The dissent. Judge Ho saw "two competing narratives." Either officials were punishing "a political detractor for his personal decision not to shake hands with them," or the coach was facing "legitimate discipline for refusing to do his job." Which one is right, he wrote, turns on whether this was private or government speech, and "[t]hat's a fact question." He noted that Kennedy "was decided on summary judgment," after discovery showed the scope of that coach's duties. Here, he wrote, "there's been no factual development of what those duties actually entail." Taking the complaint as true, he would have let the claim go forward: "That should be enough to overcome a motion to dismiss."

Why this matters

For Texas public employees, much turns on the first question: were you speaking as a citizen, or doing your job?

If you work for a Texas school district, city, or county and believe you were disciplined for something you said or did outside your job duties, the details of your job, the setting, and your audience will matter. Read more about First Amendment retaliation claims.

This post is for general information only. It is not legal advice and does not create an attorney-client relationship. Every case depends on its own facts, and past results do not guarantee future outcomes.

Attorney responsible for content: Brandon J. Grable, Grable PLLC, 12451 Starcrest Dr, Suite 206, San Antonio, TX 78216, (210) 963-5297, intake@grable.law. Office visits are by appointment only; calls and emails are accepted 24/7.

Topics: First Amendment

How Grable PLLC Can Help

First Amendment Rights

Speech retaliation, recording police, protests, public employee speech, and anti-SLAPP defense.

Section 1983 & Police Misconduct

Unlawful arrests, excessive force, retaliation, and other constitutional violations by police and government officials.

Recording Police in Texas

General information on the right to record police in public, retaliation, and phone seizures.

See also: case results and case updates.

Talk with Grable PLLC. Call 210-963-5297 or email intake@grable.law.

Request a Consultation