First Amendment Rights
Speech retaliation, recording police, protests, public employee speech, and anti-SLAPP defense.
Case: In re Application of the United States of America for an Order Pursuant to 18 U.S.C. Section 2703(d), No. 26-4303, ___ F.4th ___, 2026 U.S. App. LEXIS 34503 (4th Cir. Nov. 10, 2026) (published; opinion by Judge Wilkinson, joined by Judges Wynn and Berner). Read the opinion
A news outlet published an article that revealed classified information about a United States military operation abroad. Investigating the leak, federal prosecutors got two court orders under the Stored Communications Act. One required LinkedIn to turn over 18 months of messaging and connection records (metadata) for journalists affiliated with the outlet. The other barred LinkedIn, for one year, from telling anyone other than its lawyers that the order existed.
LinkedIn asked the court to narrow both orders, and the district court refused. On Nov. 10, 2026, the Fourth Circuit affirmed in part, reversed in part, and remanded. It held that "neither the Stored Communications Act nor the Constitution permit the district court to approve orders that by all apparent indications are substantially overbroad," and sent the case back so the orders can be drawn more narrowly. It did not quash the orders entirely.
The opinion speaks generally because of national security concerns, and it does not name the news outlet or the journalists.
According to the court, the disclosure order covered an eighteen-month period in which the targeted journalists published "nearly 1,000 different articles" on a range of topics, "less than five percent" of which appeared to have anything to do with the leak. The records would identify everyone the journalists corresponded with on LinkedIn about any of those stories, including confidential sources with no apparent link to the investigation.
The secrecy order barred LinkedIn from disclosing the disclosure order, the secrecy order, or the government's applications to anyone except its own lawyers. LinkedIn proposed a narrow exception: let it tell one lawyer for the news outlet, so that lawyer could help identify ways to narrow the disclosure order. A magistrate judge and then the district judge sided with the government on the merits.
LinkedIn could raise the journalists' rights. The court held that LinkedIn had standing. The journalists and the news outlet could not protect their own First Amendment interests because the secrecy order kept them in the dark, and LinkedIn markets itself to journalists. The government's argument that LinkedIn's size (over one billion members) defeats a close relationship with its users did not persuade the court.
The government's interest is strong, but not unlimited. The court stressed that "[t]he government's strong national security interest in this case need not be submitted to proof; it is self-evident." The government is entitled to a disclosure order, and "[i]t is even entitled to a broad disclosure order. But it is not entitled to carte blanche."
Courts must police overbreadth. Under the statute, a disclosure order may issue only if the government offers "specific and articulable facts" showing reasonable grounds to believe the records are "relevant and material" to an ongoing criminal investigation. The court held that "[p]lainly irrelevant or immaterial records encompassed in a § 2703(d) order constitute impermissible overbreadth," and that "[t]here is no express exception for national security." It also said "[i]t is not appropriate for district courts to approve requests purely because the records requested are logistically feasible to compile."
The First Amendment adds weight when journalists' sources are at stake. "Confidentiality of sources is the lifeblood of a free press," the court wrote. Applying Justice Powell's concurrence in Branzburg v. Hayes, the court held that when part of a records request seeks records with only a "remote and tenuous" relationship to the investigation, "and especially where that request implicates confidential source relationship[s]," "the district court must conduct a balancing analysis." That inquiry does not create a separate test: "the First Amendment inquiry merges with and strengthens the tailoring requirements in 18 U.S.C. § 2703(d)."
Applying those rules, the court concluded that the disclosure order, "in its present form," is "substantially overbroad," and that respect for the government's investigation "does not translate into license to round up indiscriminately the identities of confidential and unrelated newsgathering sources." On remand, the district court must weigh the government's need, the breadth of the request and whether it can feasibly be subdivided, the fact that relevance is hard to know early in an investigation, and the First Amendment and statutory standards.
The gag order is a prior restraint. "The Secrecy Order is also a prior restraint," the court held, noting that the parties agreed on that point. National security leak investigations will often justify secrecy, but the district court still had to engage with LinkedIn's narrow proposal. The court directed: "Unless the government's response to LinkedIn's proposal is more persuasive than anything the government has presented thus far, LinkedIn's narrow exception to the breadth of the Secrecy Order must be adopted."
No access to the government's secret filings. The court affirmed the denial of LinkedIn's request to see the government's ex parte submissions, finding no abuse of discretion in giving primary weight to the government's need to keep them confidential.
For more on free-speech and free-press rights, see our First Amendment rights page.
This post is for general information only. It is not legal advice and does not create an attorney-client relationship. Every case depends on its own facts, and past results do not guarantee future outcomes.
Attorney responsible for content: Brandon J. Grable, Grable PLLC, 12451 Starcrest Dr, Suite 206, San Antonio, TX 78216, (210) 963-5297, intake@grable.law. Office visits are by appointment only; calls and emails are accepted 24/7.
Topics: First Amendment
Speech retaliation, recording police, protests, public employee speech, and anti-SLAPP defense.
First Amendment, defamation, TCPA, and the right to record police and public officials.
Unlawful arrests, excessive force, retaliation, and other constitutional violations by police and government officials.
General information on the right to record police in public, retaliation, and phone seizures.
See also: case results and case updates.
A divided Fifth Circuit held a Brownsville coach did not plausibly allege that refusing board members' handshakes was citizen speech.
The Sixth Circuit held a school's cease-and-desist letter to a parent critic plausibly violated the First Amendment, and remanded that claim.
The Seventh Circuit held Indiana's extra dues-deduction steps for public school teachers only were viewpoint discrimination and affirmed an injunction.
Talk with Grable PLLC. Call 210-963-5297 or email intake@grable.law.
Request a Consultation