Fifth Circuit again vacates injunction against Mississippi's online child-safety law, saying as-applied First Amendment relief must be built platform by platform

· 5 min read · By Brandon J. Grable

Case: NetChoice, L.L.C. v. Fitch, No. 25-60348, 2026 U.S. App. LEXIS 35336 (5th Cir. Nov. 19, 2026) (published; opinion by Judge Wilson, joined by Judges Richman and Engelhardt). Read the opinion

The short version

In 2024, Mississippi passed the Walker Montgomery Protecting Children Online Act. The law covers online platforms that let users interact with each other, create profiles, and post content. It requires covered sites to make "commercially reasonable efforts to verify" users' ages, to get the "express consent of a parent or guardian" before a known minor can hold an account, and to make efforts to "prevent or mitigate" minors' exposure to a list of harms.

NetChoice, a trade association of internet companies, sued under the First Amendment. This is the second time the case has reached the Fifth Circuit. The first time, the court vacated a preliminary injunction so the trial court could apply the Supreme Court's 2024 decision in Moody v. NetChoice, which sets the method for facial challenges. On remand, NetChoice added "as applied" language to its complaint, and the trial court again blocked the entire Act, this time only as to nine NetChoice member platforms.

On Nov. 19, 2026, the Fifth Circuit vacated that second injunction too. The court held that "NetChoice failed to demonstrate that the Act is unconstitutional as applied to its individual members' sites," and that the trial court "did not appropriately tailor the relief it issued." The case goes back to the trial court.

What the court decided

Facial and as-applied challenges are different, and the difference matters for the remedy. A facial First Amendment challenge requires showing that a substantial number of a law's applications are unconstitutional compared to its legitimate sweep. An as-applied challenge is narrower. The court, quoting Justice v. Hosemann, explained that "a developed factual record is essential," and said (citing In re Cao) that "[i]t is expressly the burden of the plaintiff bringing an as-applied challenge to adduce the facts upon which it bases its challenge."

An as-applied injunction has to be limited. Relying on Moody, the court said "an as-applied injunction is necessarily a limited one, constrained by the specifics of the factual record." Relief must be tailored to the specific unconstitutional applications of the law, plaintiff by plaintiff.

The record here was too thin. NetChoice relied on four declarations: one from its general counsel and three from YouTube, Nextdoor, and Dreamwidth. The court said they "fail to show with any particularity how the services will be affected by the Act." For X, Facebook, Instagram, Pinterest, Reddit, and Snapchat, the court found no details in the record about which products are affected, or how. Using X as an example, the court listed its many functions (feeds, direct messaging, advertising products, a shopping platform, and an AI feature) and said the record did not show which of them the Act reaches. The general counsel's statements that the Act is burdensome were, in the court's words, "wholly unspecific."

A blanket injunction is facial relief by another name. The trial court barred enforcement of every provision of the Act against the nine platforms. The Fifth Circuit called that "strikingly facial." On remand, NetChoice must show how each section of the Act is unconstitutional as applied "member-by-member, function-by-function, and statutory section-by-section," and the trial court must analyze the claims with the same specificity.

What the court did not decide. The court did not hold that the Act is constitutional. It held that the record did not support the injunction that was entered. The court also rejected Mississippi's argument that the trial court had defied the court's earlier mandate, noting the "murky" state of the law in this area.

Earlier history. Mississippi had asked the Fifth Circuit to stay the second injunction while the appeal was pending, and the court did. The Supreme Court left that stay in place. The opinion notes that Justice Kavanaugh, concurring in the denial of the application to vacate the stay, wrote that NetChoice had "demonstrated that it is likely to succeed on the merits" under current First Amendment precedents, but that the application should be denied "because NetChoice has not sufficiently demonstrated that the balance of harms and equities favors it at this time."

Why this matters

For more, see our posts on the Fifth Circuit's Mississippi DEI law ruling, which also applied Moody, and on the Eleventh Circuit's Florida HB 3 social media decision, and our First Amendment rights page.

This post is for general information only. It is not legal advice and does not create an attorney-client relationship. Every case depends on its own facts, and past results do not guarantee future outcomes.

Attorney responsible for content: Brandon J. Grable, Grable PLLC, 12451 Starcrest Dr, Suite 206, San Antonio, TX 78216, (210) 963-5297, intake@grable.law. Office visits are by appointment only; calls and emails are accepted 24/7.

Topics: First Amendment

How Grable PLLC Can Help

First Amendment Rights

Speech retaliation, recording police, protests, public employee speech, and anti-SLAPP defense.

Section 1983 & Police Misconduct

Unlawful arrests, excessive force, retaliation, and other constitutional violations by police and government officials.

Recording Police in Texas

General information on the right to record police in public, retaliation, and phone seizures.

See also: case results and case updates.

Talk with Grable PLLC. Call 210-963-5297 or email intake@grable.law.

Request a Consultation